Arakan segregation takes toll on local communities

By HANNA HINDSTROM
Published: 25 January 2013
H-Rohingya
A Rohingya child peers into a tent at Ohn Daw Gyee displacement camp outside Sittwe, December 2012. (Hanna Hindstrom)

An angry policeman gestures and shouts in Arakanese. The road is blocked with wooden fences and cords of barbed wire. A local man wrapped in a puffy coat and woollen hat jabs a defiant finger back at the officer.

“They say I can’t go through because I am Muslim,” mutters Aung Win, a local Rohingya interpreter from Sittwe. “But I am not afraid – I am a Burmese citizen,” he says, pulling out a pink identity card.

Sittwe’s Muslim quarter, Aung Mingalar, has been cordoned off from the rest of the town since June last year, when the region was swept by its first wave of vicious sectarian clashes that destroyed thousands of homes. Since then, over 7,000 Muslims – mostly from the stateless Rohingya minority – have been trapped inside.

“I’ve lost everything,” says Mohammed Rafi, whose house was torched to the ground on the same day that his father-in-law was hacked to death with machetes. A few days later the police evicted him from his pharmacy in downtown Sittwe market.

“They just told me to leave. I didn’t even have the time to gather all my things,” explains the 49-year-old. “Now I have no earnings.”

Isolated from the economic hub of downtown Sittwe, Aung Mingalar is facing a growing humanitarian crisis. Food supplies are short and prices soaring; the only healthcare facility in the area is barred shut because there are no supplies. Despite fresh pledges of government and international aid, locals insist that the ongoing policy of segregation is a much bigger problem.

“If they gave us the security and allowed us to go the market, then I think that could easily solve the problem,” says Rafi. “The Rakhine [Arakanese] can go to the market and they can go to the hospital, but we cannot.”

The government claims that segregation aims to protect both communities, yet Buddhists and Hindus are able to travel freely. Even Kaman Muslims, who are Burmese citizens, but share cultural commonalities with the Rohingya community, face restrictions. One Kaman woman told DVB that her brother was arrested and beaten by policemen for trying to leave Aung Mingalar.

The Rohingya have been described as one of the world’s most persecuted minorities. They have lived in limbo along the border with neighbouring Bangladesh since 1982, when former military dictator Ne Win stripped them of their Burmese citizenship. Although they have been denied basic rights for decades, locals say they have become increasingly ostracised since last year’s violence.

Many nationalists, who consider them illegal immigrants from Bangladesh, have urged Buddhists not to associate with the group and called on the government to enforce permanent segregation. The Rakhine Nationalities Development Party has declared it “impossible” for the two communities to coexist again. Many Arakanese locals, who lost houses or family in the clashes, are equally sceptical, with some suggesting Rohingyas should be relocated to a third country.

But Buddhist communities have suffered under segregation, too. Ma Thein Nu, a local Arakanese woman who trades with Muslims, told DVB that she lives in constant fear of radical nationalists, who don’t want the two groups to trade. It follows news that extremists have targeted so-called “Rohingya sympathiser” by publicly shunning or abusing them.

“Twice [a group of monks] stopped me and took over 200 dollars worth of food,” she explains. “I am afraid, but I have no other choice. I have to feed my family.”

“I have no job to get money for food”

She now trades at Tè Chaung market on the outskirts of the city, where 75,000 uprooted Rohingyas are crammed into makeshift camps – many without toilets or clean water supplies – and survive on small portions of plain rice. They are not allowed to enter downtown Sittwe and very little aid trickles through. Without trade they would struggle to survive.

“Segregation affects both communities economically, but its impact on the Muslim communities is absolutely disastrous,” says Chris Lewa, head of the Arakan Project. “It curtails their livelihoods, confines them to squalid camps or ghettos making them dependent on humanitarian aid whose delivery is hampered by security threats on aid workers.  [Seven] months on – this is outrageous, unsustainable and inhumane.”

A local doctor explains that they have only recently been able to refer ill patients from the camps to Sittwe hospital, after an aggressive lobbying campaign by the Red Cross. “But it is still completely impossible outside the Sittwe area,” he says, adding that maternal deaths and stillborn children are commonplace.

According to government figures, an additional 50,000 predominantly Muslim people across Arakan state have lost their livelihoods because they can’t travel to work. The fishery sector, which provides jobs for many locals, has been particularly affected. But only those people who lost homes in the violence qualify for aid.

“IDPs [internally displaced persons] are getting some food from the World Food Programme, but the host communities are not getting any assistance from any agencies because they are not registered by the government,” explains Abdul, a former electrical engineer, who has been unemployed for nearly seven months.

“I have no job to get money for food,” he says. “But I have a brother who is an IDP from downtown Sittwe. He gets enough food for his family, so I have to ask him to provide some for me.”

Despite public pledges to improve stability in the conflict-torn state, the government has failed to set a timeline for reintegration. According to Refugees International, they have indicated that it could take up to three years before displaced communities can return. The group warned that separation could become permanent if donors fail to vocalise their objections.

The UN insists that reintegration must form a fundamental part of any rehabilitation strategy in the devastated region. “We need the opportunity for these communities to trade with each other and eventually coexist with each as they have done in the past for many years,” says Ashok Nigam, UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Burma.

“Clearly security and rule of law is paramount for the government at this point, but it should be implemented in a manner that does not constrain people from moving and earning livelihoods.”

The UN Refugee Agency recently warned that over 2,000 Rohingyas have fled Arakan state since the start of 2013 – and more than 13,000 last year. Activists say this number is likely to rise as segregation continues into its seventh month.

“The union government is not interested in reconciling Rohingya and Rakhine people,” sighs Aung Win. “They want to divide us for a long time.”

Tags: , , ,

Author:              Category: Uncategorized

Comments


  1. Andre Leroux says:

    Divide, Isolate, Concentration camp, Ideal recipe for Holocust.
    My prayer for the Rohingas.

  2. Karl says:

    nice that Muslims in distress receive attention. Now, how about the Greeks that were displaced by the Muslim Apartheid Occupation of Northern Cyprus? Or are the wonderful people of Norsk, too busy building illegal vacation settlements there?

  3. Andre Newman says:

    The old theory
    Divide and Rule.

    But for how long?
    The military used the monks.
    Now Suu Kyi wants to use the monks,
    to prolng anty Rohingya attitude.

  4. Arnold Barua says:

    The Myanmar government, Buddhist monks and Suu Kyi has to accept the reality of Rohiynga people.
    For too long Rohingas has been deprived, Suu Kyi was deprived only for 15 years.
    Lets nominate the Rohingas for Noble prize. We need Suu kyi’s
    endorsement.

  5. decolonizationofburmaarakan says:

    it is due time for UN to send peace making troops where are daily killed due to restrictions made by central government. we believe that UN will not stand away from its commitments formed in their organization. UN must concentrate without any delay to rescue the Rohingya from the world worst Liar, President thein sein.Arakan, Rakhine northern part is the native land of the Rohingya.

  6. UnionStarJournal says:

    An internal dispute of many issues. As it’s internal (domestic), no int’l group of any kind should be allowed to intervene. Sooner or later it will be resolved, by wisely and professioinally communications of both communities involved. Leaders of Myanmar Union should strive to consider those community’s socio-cultural, economic, and political history and its potential impact on the regional and national stability, peace and security issues. Religion(faith) difference alone should not be considered a serious problem. If they truly want to live in harmony and do consider to be citizens of Union of Myanmar, they must not do anything againt the national objectives of stability, peace and security etc, and will be subject to legal punishments by the nation. All communities living in a certain area or region should be considerate of each other, especially try not to offend other people’s socio-cultural and economic living situations. Not only Myanmar Union, but also the world powerful nations even accuse the muslins as extremists or terrorists. Show those around you that you are not so, and you are good people, by what you say, by the way you do things, by the way you associate with others. Those of non-muslin people in Myanmar, think of this issue not as just an issue, but as a national issue in terms of building democracy and united strong and powerful nation. Let them in, if they are willing to live by the society’s values, and watch over them, cooperate with them, help them to become a as productive and helpful community as others in the Union. Or, if they violate, let the local know first, and then the Union and then the global community know via media, and then try to appropriately correct by all means. Let all religions, communities know the Union’s central objectives and goals,and get them to help implement the tasks.Any body of either side who makes the dispute or conflict, regardless of the person’s faith, should be severely punished,under Union’s…

  7. N Nabi says:

    To Union Star Journal,
    THANKS for your passionate saying.

    I hope God gives Myanmar people and their government the virtue for a peaceful co existence.





Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

 characters available
 

Other Uncategorized Stories

DVB TV

Inle water shortage

MOST READ STORIES

 

You need to log in to vote

The blog owner requires users to be logged in to be able to vote for this post.

Alternatively, if you do not have an account yet you can create one here.

Powered by Vote It Up

Marquee Content Powered By Know How Media