Burmese generals ‘hate China’, says India

By JOSEPH ALLCHIN
Published: 27 December 2010

Than Shwe walks with Chinese President Hu Jintao during a September visit to Beijing (Reuters)

Burma’s hermetic military rulers detest their strongest ally, China, according to an Indian official quoted in a leaked US diplomatic cable.

Washington’s Consul General in India, Peter Kaesthner, also explains in the cable that India feels its position on Burma is compromised by persistent US pressure to be more vocal about rights and democracy.

India, which does not want to be castigated for engaging the Burmese generals, has often rued external pressure. Delhi’s position is that engagement will be more productive than the condemnation of the junta expressed by the majority of western democracies.

The cable dates from 2007, and documents a conversation between Kaesthner and Mohan Kumar, the joint secretary of India’s Ministry of External Affairs.

“The more the US presses India to bring Burma before the UN Security Council, [Kumar] said, the more the Burmese tell India to ‘go to hell’,” Kaesthner wrote.

Furthermore, if India engages the generals, then Burma will be able to loosen China’s grip on the country.

“Burmese officials have told Kumar that they ‘hate’ the Chinese and would prefer not to cooperate with China, but do so because they feel Beijing is more reliable than New Delhi”.

No elaboration is given on how India would promote democracy in Burma, were it to be closer to the ruling junta. But, tellingly, the cable reveals that economic objectives in its relations with its eastern neighbour remain key.

While India has sought to increase investments in Burma over the past two decades, particularly in the energy sector, Kumar reportedly told Kaesthner that, “We’re getting screwed on gas”.

“India is not getting any gas contracts from Burma, nor is it getting the transit rights it seeks which would open a bridge to East Asia,” Kaesthner wrote.

This raises an important, but often overlooked, Indian imperative: that whilst China seeks a strategic gateway to the Indian Ocean via Burma, India in turn would seek to use the pariah as its own access point to the growing eastern economies.

It also perhaps alludes to an Indian understanding of US imperatives that look to counter China’s influence in the region.

Moreover, while references to the promotion of democracy arise frequently in the cable, it also makes mention of Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Pakistan, countries where China’s influence is growing and where both India and the US are keen to stem this.

Since the cable was sent in 2007, India has seemingly moved beyond the unidimensional level of cooperation over counterinsurgency on the troubled border to eye with increasing fervour Burma’s vast natural gas capacity.

Delhi has gained a stake in the Shwe gas project and has come closer to developing some of Burma’s hydropower potential, whilst bilateral trade has also increased significantly.

Tension between India and China has been a recurrent theme since the two nations fought a short war in 1962 over their disputed, ill-defined Himalayan border. The tensions persist to this day with Chinese claims for the Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh.

Despite trade between the two nations expanding rapidly before a recent visit to Delhi by Chinese Premiere Wen Jiabao, Beijing has described the bilateral relationship as “very fragile”.

Author:              Category: News, Politics

Comments


  1. Jherek Chamaeleo says:

    Imagine what lies below all that silt washed down the Ganges and Irrawaddy

    BE AHAD

    there is a date in Paradise

    Rebuilding Atlantis in the Bay of Bengal

  2. Malihkrang says:

    Look at Than Shwe’s face, dead-man walking with Chinese Premiere.

  3. Win Tun says:

    You are right Malihkrang,Than shwe is dead man.All of the country leaders said,talking with burma junta is like ,they are talking with DEAD MAN.Because they never listen.
    When they sick ,they go foreign country for medical chack up,when the country is sick they not listen others country say.

  4. Dal says:

    The above photo represents Than Shwe and Hu Jintao, not Wen!

  5. hla thein says:

    Yes,the chinese was showing his grave.

  6. Derek Tonkin says:

    One minor detail. Peter Kaestner was the Chargé at the time and so the cable was formally sent in his name. The actual talks recorded were between the Political Counsellor Ted Osius and Mohan Kumar.

  7. ben says:

    It is blunt, very blunt.
    What does it all saying to US administration is that stop wasting your time. get off your ass, your blaming games and lip servicing nonsenses of more than 20 years. Stop!
    Start a comprehensive engagement with the military regime and in 5 years time you will thank me for it.
    Trust me. I am experienced and know what I am talking about.
    with metta
    ko benya

    Do something else which is full engagement

  8. Jherek Chamaeleo says:

    Than Shwe is telling himself “Just wait until I tell Henry Kissinger that Yangon’s ‘Shin Thant’ serves better Peking Duck!”

  9. Nyunt Han says:

    Look at the above photograph.
    The article should be appropriately re-captioned “Dead man walking” !

  10. Alan says:

    “Moon walk” by Michael Jackson was a success.
    “Dead man walk” by than shwe is a flpop.

  11. Lady Gaga says:

    Than Shwe dances to Poker Face on XBox Kinect

  12. Fook-kaung says:

    Moon walk. Dead man walk. How about walking upside down on the ceiling.
    Who can do it?

  13. aung swe says:

    Let China offers poison to Than Shwe with a golden cup and return he lets China suck out the wealth of Burma. He brain wash and lie the army at the academy graduation. Than Shwe and his followers are all ignorance and stupid. They’re smart in a bad way, but not running the country.

  14. Peter Parker says:

    I have a photo of Spider Man swinging through the streets near the Port in Yangon.

  15. Capo says:

    There will be a biggest World Leaders Summit in the underground of Naypyidaw, Myanmar in 2020. Adolf Hitler, Mao Tse Dong, Mousolini, Osama Bin Laden, Didi Amin, Kim Jong iL, Omar Al Bashir, Saddam Hussein, Joseph Stalin, Polpot, Laloo of Bihar, Alex Lukashenka, Ne Win and Than Shwe will be knighted by Satan with the title of S which is not ” Sir” but Satan. After being knighted, they will carry the title in front of their names such as Satanic Hitler, Satanic Kim, Satanic Than Shwe etc. As Satan is now very old and half-paralysed like Than Shwe, he is going to die soon. Before he die, he wants to choose among his children to succeed him to fight against Jesus empire.

    Than Shwe is a front runner while Adolf Hitler is an underdog. Saddam Hussein will likely partner Bin Laden for his running mate. Than Shwe will be strongly supported by Mao, Laloo and Polpot as they are all of Asian origins.

    Didi Amin will partner Alex Lukashenka of Belarus. Omar Al Bashir from Sudan and Kim Jong iL from North Korea will partner while Stalin and Mousolini will run independently. Ne Win will pull out himself of the race as the race will be too tight for him. The opinion poll will be 77% chance to Than Shwe with Omar & Kim will be second and Saddam & Laden in third.

    Satan favourite grandchild Mr. USDP of Myanmar will be named ambassador to Hell. Saun Aa-Shin party will take role of Home Ministry. Than Shwe will declare World Road Map to Demoncracy to demonize earth. Omar & Kim will declare Sick Party Talk and Saddam & Laden will declare Terrorcracy to terrorize earth.

  16. Nyunt Han says:

    @ Capo

    All this time Mahmoud Ahmadinejad would be grumpy as he had been excluded from this World Leaders Summit with the result that he will develop nuclear arsenal and nuke the earth.
    He will then be laughing all the way to heaven with a fistful of Viagra and have a whale of a time with seventy two virgins until he can’t stand up anymore !





Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

 characters available
 

Other News, Politics Stories

DVB TV

MPs returned to Parliament in Burma’s capital Naypyidaw

MOST READ STORIES

 

You need to log in to vote

The blog owner requires users to be logged in to be able to vote for this post.

Alternatively, if you do not have an account yet you can create one here.

Powered by Vote It Up

Marquee Content Powered By Know How Media