
So far, March has been a bad month for those countries and so-called Burma experts who advocate for a softer line with Burma’s generals. First were the admissions by the US that its engagement policy was going nowhere; then came the publication of election laws in Burma that don’t give the slightest concession to calls that elections this year be free and fair; and finally the recommendations by the UN special rapporteur on Burma that there be a UN Commission of Inquiry into war crimes and crimes against humanity being committed by the dictatorship. The true nature of Than Shwe and the general’s around him has been revealed again.
The argument over what the international community should do about the situation in our country has grown in recent years. What has surprised me is how badly informed that debate has been, and how willing some people and countries are to turn a blind eye to the reality of what is going in my country. Some people are even worse, playing down the human rights abuses and trying to put a positive spin on the actions of the generals.
What governments and the UN have consistently failed to do is to look at the true nature of the people ruling Burma. Only when you understand them and what they do can you work out how to deal with them.
As a Karen woman growing up in eastern Burma I know this true nature first-hand. I have seen the bodies of villagers and farmers, met the women who have been raped and the orphans whose parents were killed. Like thousands of others I have had to flee for my life as mortar bombs exploded in my village, fired at civilians without warning. Now, finally, the UN’s own Burma expert has described these as possible war crimes and crimes against humanity.
The international community, especially the UN, prefers to ignore what is happening to ethnic people in eastern Burma. Instead they focus on Rangoon and Naypyidaw, and on topics like who gets to meet Aung San Suu Kyi, or can someone repair the roof of her house; but what political significance does that have? When decisions on what to do about the crisis in Burma descend to such ridiculous things, I sometimes feel despair.
And even when the abuses happen right in front of them, how short their memories are. The massacre of thousands in 1988, the crushing of student protests in the mid-1990s, and the firing on monks in 2007, all seem forgotten. The generals defy the UN, draft a constitution that legalises dictatorship, and still the UN and others tell us to wait and see: perhaps they’ll change their mind so let’s wait for election laws, they say.
Now the election laws have been published and of course they are not fair. Did they forget that these are the generals who refused to accept the results of elections in 1990? Have the generals given any indication that they are genuinely interested in reform of the welfare of the people? None at all. It is less than two years since they were prepared to let thousands die in the delta after cyclone Nargis, rather than accept international aid. It is only three weeks since they fired a mortar bomb at a school in Karen state, killing one child and injuring two more.
They still have more than 2,100 political prisoners in jail, and arrest more daily. How clear do the generals have to make it before the international community understands that they are not interested in reform? The nature of these generals is to stay in power. They were brought up under the Tatmadaw [Burmese army] slogan: One Blood, One Voice, One Command. They gained their rank fighting ethnic people, and using the Four Cuts policy where civilians are deliberately targeted, where babies were put in rice pounders and crushed to death, and where women and children were raped as part of official government policy. Even girls as young as five have been raped.
When diplomats and so-called experts sit down with those generals in Rangoon and Naypyidaw and think that somehow they will be the one who will negotiate a breakthrough, remember the true nature of the people you are dealing with. Don’t be fooled by the smiles and plush buildings. The generals you shake hands with are brutal killers. Even the UN’s own expert says responsibility for the abuses in Burma go right to the top. They are not diplomats or politicians, they are soldiers. The generals will never, ever, negotiate themselves out of power unless they are forced to do so.
They are, however, good at playing games with an international community that seems desperate to believe their lies. So within the next few days or weeks we can expect some new so-called concessions from the generals, perhaps letting opposition National League for Democracy (NLD) party leaders meet Aung San Suu Kyi, or the release of a high profile political prisoner. Once again we will see governments and others attach imaginary significance to this, still ignoring the true nature of the people they are dealing with.
Zoya Phan is international coordinator at Burma Campaign UK. Her autobiography, ‘Undaunted’, will be published in hardback in the US in May, and published as ‘Little Daughter’ in paperback in the UK in May.
Tags: Elections, Karen, UN, US
The blog owner requires users to be logged in to be able to vote for this post.
Alternatively, if you do not have an account yet you can create one here.
Powered by Vote It Up
is clear as day that the UN is hostage to the Chinese government! China patner trade with dictators, I will define protectors, because in China there are no human rights, and defend them forever. is very sad to know that the strongest economy in the world is founded on slavery and that Burma is a country by sucking its resources, to China! The Beijing government has said bad things about Obama because he received the Dalai Lama (genocide in Tibet) … put pressure on China to free Burma otherwise no hope for Aung San Suu Kyi and her beautiful, wonderful people.
The people of Burma need justice from the world community, not the line of appeasement the U.N follows. AT least one person in the U.N has stood up and said that there are crimes. Then the U.N must bring Thitsaphout Than Shwe to trial, they must launch an invasion of Burma, to free the people from this nightmare.
I couldn’t agree more with the above commentator. SPDC (Burmese generals) have been bribing the immediate neighbours , China, India, Thailand (especially China )by giving away the country’s natural resources in exchange for China’s VETO at the UN Security Council.
Meanwhile, people of Burma have to go without electricity , clean water and proper sanitaion systems.
The country has been deteriorating in “Every aspect” due to the generals’ greed, incompetence, corruption and determination to hold on to absolute power since 1962.
This is not an election….This is a dirty game…..This 2010 election game can’t change any things in Burma.
I think most countries and world leaders are not ignorant of what is going on in Burma and they are not fooled by the generals. I think they are struggling to find a way to get significant progress toward peace in Burma. They probably read too much into things at times and clutch at straws in the hope for peace. They are also hamstrung by the reality of having to forge relationships with significant strategic powers like China and India despite their support for the regime.
What they really need is not a lecture about how bad things are but some ideas on how to make some progress after all these years and with the political and economic realities of the world in mind. Burma Campaign UK doesn’t really seem to have a strategy beyond sanctions which don’t seem to be working. If leaders of democratic nations make mistakes in their dealings with Burma then it is mostly out of a concern for progress, not ignorance or a lack of care.
Brothers and sisters take notice of this and read it.
Dear Brothers and Sisters of the world
In a major victory for Burma campaigners, Australia is the first country to publicly announce its support for a UN Commission of Inquiry into human rights abuses in Burma.
In a statement at the UN Human Rights Council earlier this week Australia’s representative to the council, Angela Robinson, said: “Australia would support investigating possible options for a United Nations commission of inquiry”.
Your support and actions have made this possible.
By raising your concerns for Burma in letters, emails and petitions you have increased the Australian Government’s awareness on Burma. Because of your efforts, they have taken action. Congratulations!
How blind can UN and SPDC appeasers be.
The dictators of Burma from NeWin[1962] down till ThanShwe now close to 50 years were/are incorrigibly perverse.
Pre-colonial “Burma” isn’t much better listening to Burmese poets of the past.
Yes history has not been kind to the peoples of Burma.
“Can leopard change its spots or an Ethiopian it’s skin”
“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”
Close to 50 Million are now enslaved in their own country by an illegitimate Govt and yet the “august” UN body stands by doing practically nothing but grin and from time to time growl and bares its toothless mouth.
Matt Grant is talking nonsense. The world care more about making money than is does about children in Burma being raped. Sanctions would work if they were applied.
Its commont sense, the regime needs money to buy arms, cut the money supply of and the regime would have less money to spend on arms!
I am afraid after 62 years of civil war that neither sanctions as have been mentioned or new ideas or reasons for political dialogue will work with the evil dictatorship. We need either an invasion (which wont happen because there is no oil in Burma) or UN intervention to stop the genocide of my prescious Karen brothers & sisters. Unfortunately it is not political salvation that will save the people of Burma. But us all joining together in Unity who are working together for a Free Burma. Even the 500 NGO’s including our Christian Organizations do not work together in Unity. Someone needs to rise up like Zoya Phan and unify all of us who are tirelessly working seperately to bring about peace and work hand in hand in bringing awareness to the situation throughout the world as the tea party’s and such did 225 years ago in America. When we work together we can be a strong force when we are divided we fall and so does our goals and purpose.
“Only when you understand them and what they do can you work out how to deal with them. ” I agree this. You must know the history of Burmese Kings and Rulers. Burma is not under the Democratic government. So we could not choose the ways what dealing with in the west. Must find the correct way only then solve the problem.
“”still the UN and others tell us to wait and see”" for giving chances to control everything under them and destroying us systematically?
“”The generals will never, ever, negotiate themselves out of power unless they are forced to do so.”" you know the past very well and must get the lessons from there
It is surprising that at the recent Human Rights Commission meeting in Geneva only the US (first) and then Australia (second) supported Quintana’s suggestion that UN institutions might like to consider a Commission of Enquiry. That makes only 2 out of 22 country representatives who spoke. Even Quintana didn’t raise this orally at the meeting, though it was in his report. I had expected the EU, Italy, UK, Norway, Switzerland and Belgium to support Quintana’s suggestion, but they didn’t. So far, that only makes one country out of 15 in the UN Security Council in favour of a Commission of Enquiry. Australia might get a seat on the Council in 2013-2014. On the other hand, China, Laos, Vietnam, Malaysia and Bangladesh avoided criticism of the election process and gave encouragement to Myanmar to persist. In short, the international community is as divided as ever on what to do for the best.
Thanks this is the information that everyone should read and observe cause it is for the cause of our nation and our progress thank you.
There are two ways to have real independence back from the military rule.
ONE – We, the Burmese, must fight back the junta by arms ( ambush or whatever ), even in towns and cities, everywhere, anywhere. Think thoroughly we are that brave. If not,
TWO – We need external support, not lip service and sanction only, but military aid too. We who knows what to do will go first with the plan, then only people will follow by our side as they have total fear of the regime’s abuse of authority, jailing everyone who tries to go against by unjust so-called laws.
But now as you see, we are playing by the law but the regime is not. They ever made dirty tricks to crush all of our pure attempt to democracy. So we don’t need to play by the law either any more. We will play the game as they are. How? Right?
If not, forget things about Burma and let them rule it forever.
The one we are dealing with is not a civilian goverment but a junta, military group. They think and move in military strategy and tactics. They see us in their eyes, the targets in the battle field. They are shooting down us one by one. We have to use their technique. They are our sole enemy as long as they are doing bad things to the people. We have to aim and shoot them down. Then they will never wake up to rule Burma again. They seized the people’s power in illegal ways. We must take it back in any ways possible. We can’t use the soft approach. They don’t listen. They don’t response. We must wipe them out by force. No other way.
Congratulations ZOYA.Iam proud of yoursuccess,your daddy no matter where he is now he will be very proud of your achivements.let me help you understand Gen Than Shwe.Burmas first dictator Ne Win had said “by using fear and starvation our military can rule Burma for one hundred years”.Now Than Shwe is doing just that and have succeeded for 40 years.and so will carry on until he die then the next general will carry on . understand Dictators,They will never reconsile,share power,step down,or hold fair elections,they have no tears to shed.no ears to hear pleas and critics.they only fear super power invation.just like Saddam Houssain,and they know the day will come and thats why they are making chemical weapons on Heingyi Island CHINESE MILITARY BASE now moved to BELU KYUN near MORLAMYINE as storm NARGIS destroyed the base,and they are also cleaning out ethnic people Shan and KAREN as they believe these people will help the invaders.thats why they burn the villages and drive the Karens to Thailand.now their new policy of applying fear,when ever they capture or rape or beat the Karen people they always hear “JESUS help me”and so to apply fear they CRUCIFY them,put them on cross men or woman and cut their throaths,shouting Jesus can not help he is DEAD,the soldiers are only obeying orders,so we have to remove the generals to stop their War Crimes,and Crimes against HUMANITY.for the liberation and freedom of all living in BURMA the country that I LOVE.
Obama’s four years trial and error foreign policy docterine will end up with nuclear Iran and eternal militry rule in Myanmar. Then he can come and bow King Than Shwe as he did to Saudi King.
I hope he will realise real workable foreign policy when he learn there is not earth quake in Hawaii, LOL.
Generals are not so smart, burmese porpulation is selfish, dumb and corrupt. General Ne Win’s era NLD CEC generals were replaced by young generation generals, such as General Saw Maung, General Khin Nyunt. Then Second generation of generals of 1988 era were replaced with young folks whom previously view as not sympathysing top generals that time may be they were captains or major rank.
They just carrying and will carry selfish and corrupt ideology until Myanmar become a state of China, similar to Tibet. Myanmar need fundamental changes in every direction not only government.
UN will act only and sided with Muslims when there is conflicts in Middle East, Balkan, South East Asia, India and Europe. If not just statements, enough. They are not concern Myanmar election law than illegeal boat people. For Myanmar people, we learnt that justice and freedom is prevail by ourselves not by others. God helps those who help themselves.